Bad Umpiring is killing us!

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
23.5
Tredwell to Imrul Kayes, no run, 52.4 mph, oh close again! Big appeal as Imrul attempted a heave into the leg side, but the umpire declines. Looked very close

28.5


Collingwood to Mushfiqur Rahim, 1 run, 68.0 mph, dropped oh my, what an absolute howler! Stuart Broad drops the simplest of chances at deep square leg from a top-edged sweep. Tried to take it with his fingers pointing up, but went through his hands, hit him on the face and well to the ground

Musfiqur was 24 when he was dropped.

Happens to all teams. Drop catch. Close calls everything happen to other teams as well.

a dropped catch is a fielder's mistake...while an umpiring decision is a ________ (fill in the blank). no use comparing those incomparables and if you do, then why not acknowledge how India surivived some catastrophy's in bangladesh due to dropped catches?

now i haven't see the supposed "blunders" of today, so i can't comment - will check them later on 360, but this post is a generalization based on 7 years of experience... but ordinarily, these things happen to minnow nations with an air of approval.

what happened to greg bucknor?

the annoying thing is, eendian and paki dipshits will start menstruating in their filthy dhotis/shalwars while trumpeting the arrogant bakwas which is endemic to those countries.

yes, we should have scored about 270-280, but i'm reserving judgment on our batsmen for that. yes, perhaps we should have bowled shuvo over the expensive riyad. again, that is the captains blunder. those are a "part of the game". bad officiating is not, and your praise of it exposes your rank prejudice and ignorance yet again.

the bottom line is that bangladesh have been robbed of many victories in ODIs in the last few years - and thats ignoring anything blunders from before 2007 which wouldnt have mattered anyways since we were a crap team back then.

but i suppose whining like a bitch are eendian birthrights, and eendian only, eh?

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
These are all just excuses.

thats true, its an excuse used by many teams to avoid losing to bangladesh. just ask dhoni.

[smashyboy]

Originally Posted by al Furqaan
but i suppose whining like a bitch are eendian birthrights, and eendian only, eh?

You guys have been whining every single match. It is almost like i can come up with an excuse list for a match that you are going to play and lose after 5 years . Fact is every single match is having some howlers and some marginal calls. Tendulkar had 3 bad decisions during England tour, . But we didn't whine. Ganguly had 3. Nobody has suffered more than Ganguly than from a single umpire(Bucknor). Atleast 6 or 7 bad decisions against him througouth his career. It happened. It happens It will continue to happen. India came out 1-0 from England. India had issues at sydney because clean edges were not given, edges to pad were adjudged leg before. Third umpires were not called. See that collection of goof ups in one match. That was one match. No team whines every single match they play like you guys do.

[WarWolf]

Smashyboy, please stop posting against our team here. This is our forum and we have all the rights to protest all the wrong decisions against us. Thanks for understanding.

[Ananna]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
You guys have been whining every single match. It is almost like i can come up with an excuse list for a match that you are going to play and lose after 5 years . Fact is every single match is having some howlers and some marginal calls. Tendulkar had 3 bad decisions during England tour, . But we didn't whine. Ganguly had 3. Nobody has suffered more than Ganguly than from a single umpire(Bucknor). Atleast 6 or 7 bad decisions against him througouth his career. It happened. It happens It will continue to happen. India came out 1-0 from England. India had issues at sydney because clean edges were not given, edges to pad were adjudged leg before. Third umpires were not called. See that collection of goof ups in one match. That was one match. No team whines every single match they play like you guys do.

Ha ha. You didnt??????????????????????????????
You whiners forced ICC not to select Bucknor for India games.

[smashyboy]

Originally Posted by WarWolf
Smashyboy, please stop posting against our team here. This is our forum and we have all the rights to protest all the wrong decisions against us. Thanks for understanding.

understood

[smashyboy]

Originally Posted by Ananna
Ha ha. You didnt??????????????????????????????
You whiners forced ICC not to select Bucknor for India games.

India made several complaints about bucknor over a decade. No action was taken. That was just the culmination. Asoka was another guy who haunted us for long. India didn't make complaint about him though.

************************/cricket/2004/jan/08buck.htm

[FaHiMa]

UCABD ----UMPIRES COALITION AGAINST BD ---they`ll never let us win!

[_Rafi_]

Someone lacks common sense here.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[Tiger Manc]

The umpiring was rubbish to say the least. The 2nd lbw decision against Morgan was as plumb as you can get and so was the Prior one. The umpires cost us the match.

[Tiger Manc]

Rod Tucker's mother would be ashamed of that performance. Mother Tucker

[mij]

Originally Posted by Tiger Manc
Rod Tucker's mother would be ashamed of that performance. Mother Tucker

Mother Tucker, hope he is not in next match.

[BagherBacha]

Here is the comment from our beloved coach Richard Mccines in crapinfo.com

Posted by The_Observer on (March 02 2010, 16:38 PM GMT)

No mention of the umpiring blunders?? Morgan was saved by Rod Tucker, oncve in 15.5 overs and then on 19.2 overs. You can't have more plumb LBW in cricket. Morgan was in his 20s and Mahmudullah was denied by some crazy umpiring. ICC should have measures to punish such howlers. Bangladesh could have easily won the match if Tucker wasn't this bad. Anyway, congrats England. Unlucky Bangladesh.

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
You guys have been whining every single match. It is almost like i can come up with an excuse list for a match that you are going to play and lose after 5 years . Fact is every single match is having some howlers and some marginal calls. Tendulkar had 3 bad decisions during England tour, . But we didn't whine. Ganguly had 3. Nobody has suffered more than Ganguly than from a single umpire(Bucknor). Atleast 6 or 7 bad decisions against him througouth his career. It happened. It happens It will continue to happen. India came out 1-0 from England. India had issues at sydney because clean edges were not given, edges to pad were adjudged leg before. Third umpires were not called.

bold faced lie...where did we complain every single match? nothing but a liar you are!

6-7 bad decisions in a career spanning how long? hell, ashraful has suffered twice as many in a quarter that time probably. do you see us complaining???

i'd just quit if i were you...you won't make it against me though you're welcome to try.

See that collection of goof ups in one match. That was one match. No team whines every single match they play like you guys do.

oh no?

http://www.indiancricketfans.com/sho...ghlight=umpire

http://www.indiancricketfans.com/sho...ghlight=umpire

eendian fan double standards

not actually a "bitch" thread...but has its share of bitchez as well

SL not allowed to complain

http://www.indiancricketfans.com/sho...ghlight=umpire

http://www.indiancricketfans.com/sho...light=umpiring

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by BagherBacha
Here is the comment from our beloved coach Richard Mccines in crapinfo.com

Posted by The_Observer on (March 02 2010, 16:38 PM GMT)

No mention of the umpiring blunders?? Morgan was saved by Rod Tucker, oncve in 15.5 overs and then on 19.2 overs. You can't have more plumb LBW in cricket. Morgan was in his 20s and Mahmudullah was denied by some crazy umpiring. ICC should have measures to punish such howlers. Bangladesh could have easily won the match if Tucker wasn't this bad. Anyway, congrats England. Unlucky Bangladesh.

thats just an excuse...smashyboy knows more about cricket than Richard McInnes.

[smashyboy]

Originally Posted by al Furqaan

http://www.indiancricketfans.com/sho...ghlight=umpire

It seems to haven this long to compile this list. This is a match where India won . This doesn't seem to be an excuse for loss. Some of the others are more tongue-in-cheek than this run of the mill whining i see here.

[smashyboy]

Originally Posted by al Furqaan
thats just an excuse...smashyboy knows more about cricket than Richard McInnes.

You think that happens only against Bangladesh? In the first match both cook and KP had bad decisions. You guys didn't capitalize on it.

[Ashraf-FTP]

Originally Posted by rafi_mc69
Someone lacks common sense here.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

not some, most do

[Zeeshan]

[reyme]

Mental hospital now accepting new patients: they will smash the boyz that needs to be smashed

[reyme]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
You think that happens only against Bangladesh? In the first match both cook and KP had bad decisions. You guys didn't capitalize on it.

Nobody gets day light robbed like BD.

If it was India in place of BD yesterday, you would be crying and bleeding.
First fix your one eyed view, then come back and discuss with us.

[Ajfar]

smashyboy all you do around here is look down on us, people write about UDRS you are like that's the last thing your team should worry about. what the hell does that mean? there are plenty of foreign fans around here who acknowledges good and bad stuff, you seem to only go after the bad stuff. i'm sure we have our faults, but seems like you wait for a chance to look down us.

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
It seems to haven this long to compile this list. This is a match where India won . This doesn't seem to be an excuse for loss. Some of the others are more tongue-in-cheek than this run of the mill whining i see here.

dude almost every series against white nations, tehre are similar threads. i've lost count fo them.

they even post "count" threads where they count the decisions for and against india.

have u seen that here?

tongue in cheek my brown rear end.

[al Furqaan]

Originally Posted by smashyboy
You think that happens only against Bangladesh? In the first match both cook and KP had bad decisions. You guys didn't capitalize on it.

bad umpiring decisions? no.

getting the worst, most inexperienced, legally blind umpires? yes.

getting a "hostile" umpire removed at the whim and fancy of a rich and all-mighty board? well you can figure out who did/does that, and it ain't bangladesh.

not to mention that during world cup when we thrashed you guys, many folks claimed "oh dravid should have chosen to bowl first" and other such bakwas.

[reyme]

Welcome to the club: Enamul Haq Moni