Ashwin to remain no 1 allrounder,why no Kallis no Shakib.

[horizon]

Originally Posted by Gowza
at home:

shakib: bat ave 40.5, bowl ave 35.6
ashwin: bat ave 43.35, bowl ave 24.12

away:

shakib: bat ave 33.5, bowl ave 29.32
ashwin: bat ave 30.16, bowl ave 74.77

ashwin is superior at home but away shakib is superior. but if i was picking a team i'd pick shakib for both batting and bowling, i actually think he would do better if he was playing in a better team, i think he gets a bit demoralized at times and i think it's because he feels like he's the only one really trying for the win and i think he'd strive in an environment where everyone has the winning mentality and performs, he likes to compete.

ICC ranking looks only at last 3.5 years of performance. Moreover, it doesn't distinguish between home and away performance. In a sense if you award more credit to away performance, you should also penalize for not performing at home.