Should Naeem and Mominul play in the 5th/last/FINAL ODI against WI ?

[ASM Moin]

I think Mominul Should get another chance to show his talent but Naeem has got nothing to show in a ODI match..........Zia or Omi must get a chance,i think it should be Zia for his bowling ability,good fielding,big hiting ability and recent good form.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition UA

[Shaun petr]

i didn't like Mominul inclusion at all......need to be more experienced......another ASH is on the way.

[Rubu]

Fifth is the last ODI, which happens to be the final ODI as well. Just saying.

[simon]

good question.
I say no.
Specially for Naeem, bring in Jahu for Naeem.
And probably Zia for Momin.

[shakibrulz]

Mominul, yes. Naeem, no.

[Jadukor]

5th/final/last/ultimate/terminal/series ender game er jonne I would keep mominul and replace Naeem with Jahirul to beef up the batting

[akabir77]

Originally Posted by simon
good question.
I say no.
Specially for Naeem, bring in Jahu for Naeem.
And probably Zia for Momin.

I second this

[Maysun]

Yeah, let's all just ignore Nasir because he has been the top scorer for us in the Test series and his performance so far in the ODI's is irrelevant.

Let's ignore him because he is the next big thing and it's just a blip.

If anyone deserves to be dropped first for tomorrow, it's Nasir not Naeem/Mominul.

[MyRoom]

Honestly these players deserve to be dropped from our team based on their ODI performances so far this series - Tamim, Naeem, Rahim, Nasir and Mominul. Can't believe Nazmul Hossain wasn't picked for this series, can't believe Imrul who has a very respectable ODI record wasn't picked. Our selectors or management needs to be 100% strict even on their most talented players and that means dropping i.e. Tamim Iqbal for a year. I wish I was in charge so I'd sort out everything for the betterment of our Cricket.

[zahidnyc]

no no no no noooooooooooooo , these 2 player should never get another chance to play in bd team , zia nd omi much much better player than them , and zia is thousand time better player than naeeem , naeeem should be knuck out from the team forever

[ASM Moin]

I never like a 'Khocha-Khochi' player like I.Kayes although he is technically better than many BD Batsmans.
I think the people who r against Nasir may be-
1. too much emotional or,
2. watching a ODI series of BD after 1/1.5 year

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[Shaan]

no need to change for final one, no one will bring you miracle coming on one match the tense finL. But Nayeem shuold be dropped for ODI from next series. Mominul should get one more series chance, dropping him wouldn't do any better for our future, give him enough chance along with anamul.

[ialbd]

Originally Posted by Shaan
no need to change for final one, no one will bring you miracle coming on one match the tense finL.

exactly. Right now if this team cant do it, no other team combination can...

[mali007]

Only change should be Naeem . Bring Zia so that he can bat at Riyad's position and Riyad should bat at 4 and Mushy at 3 .

[Eshen]

Originally Posted by mali007
Only change should be Naeem . Bring Zia so that he can bat at Riyad's position and Riyad should bat at 4 and Mushy at 3 .

I like the idea!

[al Furqaan]

Naeem should have been out a long time ago. Should never have played the ODIs to begin with. Mominul should get chances but bat down the order. So should Nasir.

Tamim has been a huge fat zero this entire series. First in tests and now ODIs. If he doesn't score and win us the 3rd ODI than he is no better than an Ashraful, except he knows how to run his mouth.

[Tiger444]

No point of having Naeem and Riyad in the same XI. Both are similar players except Riyad is the higher quality player in both batting and bowling. I'm not sold on Zia but he does offer variation with his power hitting and his medium pace. So Zia in for Naeem. That should be the only change IMO

[Nadim]

We need more debutants to win matches....so my vote goes to Zia ahead of jahirul

[MyRoom]

Shakib should've never played in the Champions League otherwise he would've been playing in those matches we played recently. I know money and all that but BCB should pay him more for his services.

[NoName]

Why not debut 4 new players? Worked well for the first 2 ODIs.

[Gowza]

mominul should get more chances he's new, naeem has quite a number of ODIs under his belt and some test matches to so he's accustomed to international cricket already so if he isn't performing now it's not likely he will later whereas mominul has only had a handful of chances so far, let's not throw him away yet.

[BengaliPagol]

Mominul has gotten out to playing good shots. He got caught when he went to pull, and the game before he got caught after cover driving. He is pretty much fighting his own demons. He actually hasnt looked uncomfortable when he was in the middle. He just needs to know where the fielder is and play accordingly. Other then that he should be fine. But Naeem is a huge worry and is useless in this format.

[Gowza]

Originally Posted by BengaliPagol
Mominul has gotten out to playing good shots. He got caught when he went to pull, and the game before he got caught after cover driving. He is pretty much fighting his own demons. He actually hasnt looked uncomfortable when he was in the middle. He just needs to know where the fielder is and play accordingly. Other then that he should be fine. But Naeem is a huge worry and is useless in this format.

replace naeem with shuvagata or alauddin/abul (a pace allrounder who has the potential to be a quality pacer).

[mij]

please no neaem / abul

[BengaliPagol]

Its hard to make the batting order but Mahmudullah might get a promotion
1. Tamim Iqbal
2. Anamul Haque
3. Jahurul Islam
4. Mushfiqur Rahim
5. Mahmudullah
6. Nasir Hossain
7. Mominul Haque
8. Sohag Gazi
9. Mashrafe Mortaza
10. Abdur Razzak
11. Elias Sunny